Bangalore: A recent statement by Justice V. Srishananda of the Karnataka High Court, referring to a Muslim-majority area in Bangalore as ‘mini Pakistan,’ has ignited a debate over the treatment of religious minorities in India. The judge’s comment, which described the area from Mysore Road flyover market to Goripalya as “Pakistan, not India,” raises concerns regarding societal divisions and the experiences of Muslim communities in the nation.

According to Kashmir Media Service, the comment made by Justice Srishananda has not only triggered discussions within local communities but also touched on broader issues affecting Muslims in India. Such remarks come at a time when the country grapples with questions of inclusivity and equality among its diverse populations.

Further exacerbating concerns are findings from the National Family Health Survey (NFHS), which underscore substantial socio-economic challenges faced by Muslims in India. The survey points to significant disparities, such as lower average education levels among Muslims compared to other religious groups and a higher infant mortality rate in Muslim-majority areas—about 5% above that in Hindu-majority regions. Additionally, the NFHS data indicates a higher rate of malnutrition among Muslim children under five, signaling inadequate access to essential nutrition in these communities.

These statistics are critical as they highlight the ongoing disparities faced by Muslim populations, despite India’s secular constitutional framework. Critics argue that such inequalities, combined with recent incidents perceived as biased, contribute to a growing sense of marginalization among religious minorities.

The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), holding power for three consecutive terms, has come under scrutiny from opposition parties and human rights organizations for its approach towards minorities. Despite allegations of bias, the BJP asserts that its policies are inclusive and aimed at the development of all communities, irrespective of religious affiliation.

As India marks 77 years of independence, the status and treatment of its religious minorities remain pivotal issues in both national debate and international scrutiny, reflecting on the country’s commitment to its secular and democratic values.